SEARCH
Justinian News

Criminal Code Amendment (State Sponsors of Terrorism) Bill 2025 ... Interacting with deemed state entities could land you in pokey ... Another layer of counter-terror law to make us all feel safer ... More >> 

Politics Media Law Society

My Role in Gough's Downfall ... Reporter-at-Large … Scoops that flushed out the deceit behind the Dismissal … Big anniversary chinwag in Canberra on November 11 … The combined forces of Kerr, Ellicott and cousin Garfield … Constitutional manipulation … Maurice Byers to the rescue ... Read more >> 

This area does not yet contain any content.
Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Knit one, purl one ... Iron Lady of legal rectitude endorses Gageler ... The chief justice wants judges on the straight and narrow ... The cardboard cutout model of legislative supremacy ... The evils of judicial activism ... Procrustes on the dance floor with the Legislative-Judicial Foxtrot ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


 Pay packets for top brass at the Federal Courts ... A stonking $5 million all up ... See more >> 

Justinian's Bloggers

Berlusconi's dream world ... Revenge politics in Italy ... Independence of prosecutors under attack ... Constitutional assault ... The years of lead ... Investigations reopened into old murders ... High drama at Milan's Leoncavallo ... Rome correspondent Silvana Olivetti reports ... Read more >> 

"If we’re only picking people who have got completely lily-white records then we’ll be missing out on a lot of people that can contribute to public life." 

NSW Premier Chris Minns, endorsing Mal Lanyon, his pick for Police Commissioner, whose contributions to public life include shouting drunken obscenities at a paramedic who came to his aid, and commandeering a police launch for private entertainment on New Year's eve ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Schmoozing and betrayal ... Judge Water Softener rides into Integrityville mounted high on his horse ... Judicial review of corruption finding ... Intriguing submissions ... Unprecedented assistance to morals monitor ... The scale of the sub-rosa intrigue ... Plenty to think about ... Ginger Snatch reports ... Read more >> 

Justinian's archive

News Desk Special ... Angelic death notices from the bar ... Soapy slips on FOI changes ... Unusual interlocutory costs order for Chris Dale ... Judge ticks off Abbott in letters' page ... Knock About's festive salute to the coppers ... January 19, 2015 ... Read more >> 


 

 

« Suzie Miller | Main | Tassie Tiger's Last Race »
Tuesday
Aug012023

The common law needs a backbone

Out, not out ... Broad strokes ... Limits of the common law when it comes to trust in government ... Robodebt shows how ... Cases reveal the futility of the law ... Weakness of the judicial branch in setting standards for the State ... Procrustes on a mission 

Where's Montesquieu when you need him? 

The line from cricket beard-stroking to the conclusions of the Robodebt Royal Commission is, you may think, not obvious, but observe the curious case of the dog that did not bark in the night.  

Contemplate the limitations of clearly delineated systems of law: what happens when law runs out of road.

Laws v Spirit: what would Montesquieu have made of the outbreak of old bufferdom at Lords in a recent Test match as he jotted down De l'esprit des Lois?  The whole point of Bairstow's dismissal was that there was a Law (rule) that served as the basis for the decision.  

True it is that the Law allowed a wide margin of discretion by the umpires as to whether a ball was dead or not, but the umpires once clear on that matter were then expressly empowered to determine the matter: ball not dead and player not inside his crease: out.

Broad, the man we love to hate, gave us the best lines of this turbulence in a protector, trumpeting to the Australian keeper that he would always be remembered for this infamy in dismissing Bairstow. 

Broad added that it was the worst thing he'd ever seen in cricket.  

No Stu, the spirit of the game is engaged as we contemplate the worst thing we've ever seen in cricket, which is delightfully captured in a spoof, Why Didn't Broad Walk.  

Despite massively snicking a ball to slip-catcher Michael Clarke in 2013 at Trent Bridge, detected neither by umpire Aleem Dar nor his guide dog, Broad stood his ground. Under the Law, he's only out when the umpire's finger goes up. 

The spirit of the game demanded that Broad walk, but the general consensus was that the Law prevailed.  

Cricket's tension between Law and Spirit is determined by ultimate reliance on a regime, applied by umpires. 

Unlike cricket, the common law allows for "no go" areas in legal conflict. Important issues are left, if not to a spirit of fairness, then to electoral resolution. 

Robodebt reminds us that the party with the least regulation brought to bear by our legal system, is of course, the State, aka the Crown, in its nine Australian manifestations.

Tut tut, I hear the retired colonels dissenting, we have the Rule of Law, and the Crown operates within that context. Well, never mind the list of prerogative advantages still allowed the Crown, look at how the power of the State is applied in reality, as evidenced in the Robodebt Royal Commission. 

The picture that emerged was of a devious and underhand application of power by senior elected and unelected officials, who knew that their performance could not sustain scrutiny, but who had the capacity, or so it seemed at the time, to conceal the illegitimacy of what was being done in the name of the State. 

That performance was destructive of the critical element in the process of governance, a word that appears nowhere in The Constitution or in public law remedies: trust.

I've quoted Daniel Patrick Moynihan before (a one man liberal think tank to the Nixon White house), writing in January 1969: 

"... All we know is that the sense of institutions being legitimate - especially the institutions of government - is the glue that holds societies together. When it weakens, things come unstuck."

Moynihan: legitimate institutions are glue

Robodebt revealed the capacity for our federal government to be more than merely sneaky and mean spirited: it made its demands of those most dependent and least capable of resistance, insulated (until the Royal Commission) against blowback with decisions of the AAT and advice from the Solicitor General against the scheme swept under the rug.  

Catherine Holmes was withering in her assessment of this performance, but her analysis is perhaps short in philosophical reflection on one aspect of the theory of government. 

A digital search of the three volumes of report. thus far released, reveals only a small reference to the concept of trust in government - but that reference is devastating: see Vol 2, page 341 (and generally pages 340-1):

"The Scheme's systemic failures, the effects on individuals and the consequences for the broader community have undoubtedly corroded public trust in government and its institutions. The effects of this are lasting; perhaps irreversible." 

Attempts to get the common law to police the concept of trust in government have proved even more futile than the efforts made for the protection of privacy. 

The case law invariably revolves around socially deprived groups, most typically Indigenous.  

In Tito v Waddell [No 2] [1977] Ch 106 Megarry VC disallowed the claim by the inhabitants of a small Pacific island that the British Crown acted contrary to trust and fiduciary obligations in failing to pay them the proceeds of a fund set up under a local ordinance to receive royalties for the commercial mining of phosphate. 

The court held that the statute only generated political or moral expectations distinguishable from any legal entitlement to the revenue. 

That negative outcome matches a similar claim of a British islander community against UK Government abuse of power, R (Bancoult) v Foreign Secretary (No 2) [2009] 1 AC 453, where an indigenous community sought redress against their forced removal from the Chagos Islands to make way for a US airforce base in the Indian Ocean. 

Continuing protests by the dispossed Chagosians

Notwithstanding some support from Toohey J in Mabo (1992) 175 CLR 1, 203 (and tangentially Gray J in Trevorrow v SA (2007) 98 SASR 136, 343 – 348 [994] – [1011] - the first successful Stolen Generation case - that in some circumstances the Crown could be held to have a fiduciary duty to a segment of the community, these tender saplings were hacked down, by Brennan CJ in Wik Peoples v Queensland (1996) 187 CLR 1, 96, and the SA Full Court in State of SA v Lampard-Trevorrow  (2010) 106 SASR 331, 396 – 403 [310] – [347].  

Paul Finn, then on the Federal Court bench, wrote at length on the need for remedy based trust duties to fall on government: see e.g.  Public Trusts, Public Fiduciaries (2010) 38 FedLRev 335, and other papers referred to therein. But to no avail.

Senior lawyers continue to express (inchoate) concern as to trust destroyed in government - for example Virginia Bell in her succinct report on Scott Morrison's octopus's garden of ministries:

"20. Finally, the lack of disclosure of the appointments to the public was apt to undermine public confidence in government. Once the appointments became known, the secrecy with which they had been surrounded was corrosive of trust in government." 

We create ever more elaborate mechanisms for policing poor behaviour by those in government e.g. the new NACC, but the common law's fundamental weakness in setting standards for the State remains a gaping void.  

Policing with a NACC in a culture of unclear legal standards is to rely on a goose's bridle. However, His Majesty's judges, as they were in our legal history, never forgot the beatings they received from the Stuart kings in the course of the seventeenth century (Coke CJ was only the first to be dismissed). 

The protection afforded by the Act of Settlement 1701 never afforded a mind set for tackling deficits in governmental behaviour, and judges were able to hide behind the divide in which political activity was distinguished, rather as the law did not extend to clerics in the medieval period.  

Law, not "the spirit of the game" (or electoral appeal), sets standards of acceptability. 

Until the common law grows a backbone in dealing with government, the politically dispossessed will continue to be trashed: indigenous will be removed from families and homelands, ripped off by government backed corporations, while pensioners are treated as rubbish. 

If only Anglo-Australian common lawyers were as energised over such displays as they are by the antics of Stuart Broad and two cricket teams.  

 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.